02.09.18 | 8 vs 8 | Old Charter 8 Year

American Whiskey

Today I am bringing you a discontinued offering from Buffalo Trace, the Old Charter 8 Year. Back in 2014 the Old Charter 8 Year was discontinued and replaced by the non-age stated (NAS) Old Charter 8, which is claimed to have been aged 8 seasons (whatever the hell that means). Well, long story short people felt duped by the change, while still keeping the number 8 plastered all over the bottle and so they did the “rational” next step of suing Buffalo Trace. Anyways, long story short the lawsuit was eventually dropped and now we are just left with much inferior (from what I’ve heard) NAS Old Charter 8, so how is ye olde 8-year-Old Charter? You’re about to find out!

First things first, the bottle is plastic and has a freaking party stopper. You wanna talk about nostalgia? This bottle had me reminiscing about my college days of Sailor Jerry and Jack Daniels Honey – man were those good days… Well you know looking back I wish I would have known about the Old Charter 8 year because at about $20 for a 750ml I would have been downing this stuff left and right at that price point! Besides my feelings of nostalgia, I actually kind of like plastic bottles, because they are so functional for packing on a day out in the Colorado mountains!

The Old Charter 8 year is a very light and swiggable 40% abv and is a Polish Gold in the glass with basically nonexistent legs. On the nose is a hefty harvest of corn and perfumed oak –  a slight tinge of alcohol opens up a thick honey and clove mixture. Certainly not a bad nose in the slightest bit! Very much what one can expect from a young bourbon. The palate was a slightly funky musty oak and ever so slight sprinkle of spice – black pepper and cinnamon – and a bowl of oatmeal drizzled with honey. The finish continues lightly with oak and dried grass. The finish rides off into the sunset with vanilla beans and honey.

Now at $20, if you can find it, this one isn’t half bad. Are there better ones out there around that price range, yes, but I really found the Old Charter 8 year to be perfectly fine in its own right. A light and extremely easy drinking 8-year bourbon that is perfect for swigging right out of the plastic bottle from where it resides! For myself, this is a whiskey for packing into your day long backcountry skiing trips and long day hikes, pull it out and take a quick swig, and know that you aren’t going to reach in and grab a handful of glass shards!

Have you had the Old Charter 8 year or the Old Charter 8? Would love to hear your thoughts on and as always thank you for joining along on yet another bottle journey!


The Whiskey Accountant

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s